This 12member advisory committee on human cloning convened five public meetings, each focusing on a particular aspect of human cloning. The pros and cons of human cloning 1955 words 8 pages at least 95% of mammalian cloning experiment have resulted in failure in form of miscarriages, stillbirths, and also life threatening anomalies reproduct ive cloning arguments pro and con reproductive cloning is inherently unsafe. Woo suk hwang can claim that using a skin cell from a patient and introducing it into a vacant human egg is not a process of cloning and does. Even before wilmuts announcement, human cloning had been made illegal in nearly all countries in europe and had been condemned by the council of europe council of europe 1986. Would the use of human cloning violate important moral rights. The pros and cons of human cloning georgetown university. Imagine how life would become when millions of people start looking alike, acting alike, and thinking.
Both of them give the same result which is an exact copy of an individual. According to my interview with professor peter cherbas, who works in biology department in indiana university bloomington, human cloning is a process of copying others, so compared to the normal laws of human society, it is an unnatural product, says professor cherbas, and a cloned person would not have a father and a mother just like we have, and it appears that they will have awkward position in the family which is hard to accept by cloned people. Therapeutic cloning, while offering the potential for treating humans suffering from disease or injury, would require the destruction of human embryos in the test tube. While human cloning is still a long way from being a reality, some remarkable progress have been made in animal. The ethics of human cloning and stem cell research markkula. Animal cloning offers great benefits to consumers, farmers, and endangered species. The easiest way of cloning is dna cloning, where dna segments are copied. There is an opinion that therapeutic cloning should not be used because it involves the destruction of a possible human life. The cloning could help in the long run if there are no donors available they could clone a. It will provide information on cultural ideology on cloning and the ability clones would have in health care. Some of the cons some on them are that the aging might be increased. Others see human cloning as a way to avoid passing on a deleterious gene that runs in the family without having to undergo embryo screening or embryo selection. Now congress is taking up the question of whether human cloning should be allowed.
Opinion pros and cons of cloning the new york times. A clone, like in the movie, the island, could be a source for transplant organs or tissue. Pros, cons, and environmantal impact human genetics genetics cloning is part of a study called genetics, in which humas are studying what makes us all different appearance wise. An overview of the regulation and patentability of human cloning. Reproductive cloning of human beings is illegal in every country due to the many ethical issues. The advantages and disadvantages of cloning humans as well as. If society wishes to ban inheritable genetic modification it can and should do so. Human cloning more typically refers to reproductive cloning, the use of somatic cell nuclear transfer scnt to obtain eggs that could develop. Faster growth rate animals and plants can be genetically modified to promptly mature. You might be able to provide babies with certain qualities. Cloning process and its cons and pros ayoub laissouf. Theological discourse about human cloning has adopted either of two methods and often both of practical reasoning 2. A commentary carmel shalev in december 2001, the general assembly of the united nations adopted a resolution to establish an adhoc committee to consider elaborating on an international con vention to oppose reproductive cloning of human beings. Cloning fact sheet national human genome research institute.
Pro ponents of this multiregional model emphasize fossil evidence showing. Research cloning arguments pro and con center for genetics. Procon issues and essential questions bioethics and cloning. Rebuttals to reasons for concern about research cloning. This possibility is one of incredible potential benefit for all of us. Besides, cloning human s organs might invite malpractices in our community pros and cons of cloning.
Predictive progress and prognostic views for mammalian cloning and patient benefits have been. It not just gives you an option of producing children, but it also gives you a chance to select the traits of your new little human being. Cons of cloning s human pros of cloning a human there is a possibility of faster aging. Genetics genetics have allowed for major advancements, like biotechnology and genetic. It does not refer to the natural conception and delivery of identical twins. Pros and cons of cloning from the guardian the guardian. The cloned child may feel the need to act similar or completely different to the person that they are a clone of and may feel as though they have to accomplish a certain task that they were cloned for cloning to produce. Pros and cons of replacement cloning human cloning. Committee ibc report on human cloning and international governance 2009. In the united states today, no federal law prohibits human cloning.
It involves making an entire human clone instead of just a mental copy like in digital mind cloning or just tissues and organs in therapeutic cloning. Bush on november 28, 2001, by means of executive order 237. The ethical implications of human cloning harvard university. Even though reproductive cloning is illegal, many countries legalise therapeutic cloning, which raise social implications. A few more cautious voices were heard, both suggesting some possible benefits from the. People with birth defects, such as missing limbs and back problems could switch into a healthier body. The committee is drafting a report to the legislature that is due on december 31, 2001. We can pass strong laws making reproductive cloning illegal without banning research cloning. This argument, which pits religious conservatives against a pro. Few issues linked to genetic research have raised as much controversial debate as the use of somatic cell nuclear transfer technology to create embryos. There are crops being engineered to survive unfavorable conditions such as high heat or low light. The cloning of humans is now very close to reality, thanks to the historic scientific breakthrough of dr.
Jan 24, 2020 the debate on human cloning also raises questions of human and fundamental rights, particularly liberty of procreation, freedom of thought and scientific inquiry, and right to health. Human reproductive cloning is an assisted reproductive technology that would be carried out with the goal of creating a newborn genetically identical to another human being. Jul 05, 2016 dolly wasnt the first animal to be clonedresearch on cloning had been going on since the mid20th centurybut she was the first example of successful cloning of a mammal from an adult cell. Human reproductive cloning describes the creation of a human embryo from. Some oppose therapeutic cloning because they think that by allowing therapeutic to be legal, it will eventually cause reproductive to also become more accepted human cloning and genetic modification. Cloning experts to tell house committee pros, cons. Some argue that cloning is wrong because it departs from natural, sexual pro. Transgenic crops the methods, pros and cons of gmos and biotechnology. To clone or not to clone that is the question troubling the minds of many americans and citizens all over the world. Human cloning is the creation of a genetically identical copy or clone of a human. Most arguments against human cloning are more problematic and limited in. Beneath the surface in the 2000 science fiction movie the sixth day, the height of human cloning and the way people perceive it or desire for it to be perceived manifests in such a creative way that the whole concept transcends ordinary inquiry.
Some technologies that doctors use to help infertile men or women have kids include invitro fertilization and artificial insemination female infertility. An ethical inquiry is the first publication of the presidents council on bioethics, which was created by president george w. Reproductive cloning is what the average person would refer to as human cloning. The possibility of person cloning has raised controversies. If this method became well practiced, people could do it for cosmetic issues. Is human reproductive cloning inevitable eubios ethics institute. Jun 30, 2006 rebuttals to reasons for concern about research cloning. Transgenic crops the methods, pros and cons of gmos and. Mammalian cloning and its discussion on applications in medicine. By con trast, the sense of life as a gift we cannot summon or control is. Human cloning may refer to therapeutic cloning, particularly the cloning of embryonic cells to obtain organs for transplantation or for treating injured nerve cells and other health purposes.
The very idea that cloning could one day become reality was thought to be a scientific impossibility by many experts. The pros and cons of human cloning essay 3781 words bartleby. Cloning reproduces the healthiest animals, thus minimizing the use of antibiotics, growth hormones. Technical information about the production of cloned human embryos could not and should not be suppressed. Whilst research using human embryos falls outside the charitys remit, we appreciate how important cloning of specific human cells is to the future of medical research. Aug 15, 2020 others see human cloning as a way to avoid passing on a deleterious gene that runs in the family without having to undergo embryo screening or embryo selection. Unfortunately the initial debate on this issue has been dominated by misleading, sensationalized accounts in the news media and negative emotional reactions derived from inaccurate science fiction. Similarly, developing the technology to perform genetic modifications safely in.
There is a reduced sense of individuality it may reduce the overall value of human life. It examines the extent to which human cloning is relevantly continuous with already familiar ethical contexts and issues. Reproduction reproductive cloning combined with genetic. The human genetics advisory commission hgac defines this as therapeutic cloning, differentiating it from reproductive cloning,7 both bodies claim that embryo experimentation in the first 14 days is permitted by english law, and question whether cloningin this. For example, crops can be engineered to increase crop yield. Jul 21, 2015 human cloning may refer to therapeutic cloning, particularly the cloning of embryonic cells to obtain organs for transplantation or for treating injured nerve cells and other health purposes. Labar, martin 1984 the pros and cons of human cloning, thought 59. The bacterium then reproduces identical copies of the dna sequence. Stage a class debate on the following statement from the article. Mar 27, 2001 cloning experts to tell house committee pros, cons. Essay researches and debates the pros and cons of human cloning. Human society can accept or reject any proposed technology on its own merits. In a hearing wednesday, proponents and opponents of human. The pros and cons of human therapeutic cloning in the public.
The pros and cons of human therapeutic cloning in the public debate j biotechnol. As many solutions deal with the issue of infertility, human cloning is one of them. We want to learn more about the exact process, the impacts and the pros and cons of human cloning to precise our knowledge in this topic, because swiss. See sarah graham, cloned human embryos yield stem cells, scientific. Human cloning for the last few decades, cloning was a fictitious idea that lay deep within the pages of scifi novels and movies. Request pdf the pros and cons of human therapeutic cloning in the public debate few issues linked to genetic research have raised as. Pop culture has had a lot of fun playing with the idea of human cloning, but very few people know a lot about cloning. An ethical assessment of the ethical issues pro and con. Human cloning by somatic cell nuclear transfer is arguably the most exciting and at the same.
Reproductive cloning can provide genetically related children for people who cannot be helped by other fertility treatments i. In addition, some people are in favor of human cloning as they see it as a solution to infertility female infertility. The purpose of therapeutic cloning is to clone things such as organs and tissue for patients in need see advantages and disadvantages of human cloning. However, there are other ways to treat infertility. The term is generally used to refer to artificial human cloning, which is the reproduction of human cells and tissue. There are currently several types of cloning carried out by scientists that include cellular cloning, embryo cloning, and molecular cloning. The fact that it is not a perfect toole should not mean it is outlawed all together. Infertile people or samesex couples could have children made from cloned cells. Cloning allows farmers and ranchers to accelerate the reproduction of their most productive livestock in order to better produce safe and healthy food. The pros and cons of human therapeutic cloning in the public debate.
It is currently the subject of much debate around the world, involving a variety of ethical, religious, societal, scientific, and medical issues. The pros and cons of human cloning essay 601 words bartleby. A first approach relies on a form of moral casuistry. This web page will explore the pros and cons of human cloning, and the current ability humans have to create a clone. For the sake of argument, let us assume that cloning technology has advanced to that point, opening the way to address other pros and cons of human reproductive cloning. Reproductive cloning arguments pro and con center for. Moreover, individuality and identity would be lost cloning. Couples who are unable to naturally conceive will be able to create children to whom they are a genetic relative thanks to human cloning.
497 322 559 1135 1544 1596 1339 684 1112 309 1069 395 700 1023 847 37 888 1356 1179 670 111 1803 68 1404 679 869 518 1200 49 573 752 806 953 1756